w w w . L a w y e r S e r v i c e s . i n



R. Saroja v/s The Government of Tamilnadu, rep. by its Secretary, Finance Department & Others


Company & Directors' Information:- L & T FINANCE LIMITED [Amalgamated] CIN = U65990MH1994PLC083147

Company & Directors' Information:- S P FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U65990MH1979PTC021790

Company & Directors' Information:- V L S FINANCE LIMITED [Active] CIN = L65910DL1986PLC023129

Company & Directors' Information:- L R N FINANCE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U65921TN1992PLC089288

Company & Directors' Information:- S M FINANCE LTD [Active] CIN = L65999TG1984PLC004526

Company & Directors' Information:- J R D FINANCE LTD [Active] CIN = L65999WB1993PLC058107

Company & Directors' Information:- B R D FINANCE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U65910KL1995PLC009430

Company & Directors' Information:- T C I FINANCE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U65920MH1973PLC017042

Company & Directors' Information:- A. V. B. FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED. [Active] CIN = U65993DL1992PTC049818

Company & Directors' Information:- S M L FINANCE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U65910KL1996PLC010648

Company & Directors' Information:- S B FINANCE PVT LTD [Strike Off] CIN = U65921TG1988PTC008268

Company & Directors' Information:- INDIA FINANCE LTD. [Active] CIN = L65110WB1984PLC050214

Company & Directors' Information:- TAMILNADU FINANCE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U65993TN1980PLC043959

Company & Directors' Information:- J J FINANCE CORPORATION LTD [Active] CIN = L65921WB1982PLC035092

Company & Directors' Information:- G V S FINANCE PVT LTD [Strike Off] CIN = U65921TG1988PTC008269

Company & Directors' Information:- G T P FINANCE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U65921TZ1991PLC003149

Company & Directors' Information:- S R K FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U65910UP1994PTC016038

Company & Directors' Information:- R N FINANCE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U74899DL1988PLC034289

Company & Directors' Information:- J R D FINANCE LTD [Active] CIN = U65999WB1993PLC058107

Company & Directors' Information:- C K G FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U65910KL1996PTC010147

Company & Directors' Information:- L N FINANCE LTD [Active] CIN = U65923WB1991PLC052876

Company & Directors' Information:- R K FINANCE LTD [Active] CIN = L65921WB1983PLC035896

Company & Directors' Information:- V P C L FINANCE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U65920TG1996PLC023172

Company & Directors' Information:- J S M FINANCE PVT LTD [Active] CIN = U74140MP1995PTC009542

Company & Directors' Information:- I & D FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65191TN1991PTC021369

Company & Directors' Information:- L N FINANCE PVT LTD [Active] CIN = U65929AS1992PTC003766

Company & Directors' Information:- N B A FINANCE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U74899DL1993PLC052393

Company & Directors' Information:- T P D FINANCE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U67120RJ1994PLC008051

Company & Directors' Information:- R G L FINANCE COMPANY PRIVATE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U74899DL1983PTC015809

Company & Directors' Information:- S K B FINANCE LIMITED [Amalgamated] CIN = U65999WB1996PLC082317

Company & Directors' Information:- J V FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U74899DL1985PTC067873

Company & Directors' Information:- L C J FINANCE PVT. LTD. [Active] CIN = U65921WB1995PTC068809

Company & Directors' Information:- H L T FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65921DL1996PTC078128

Company & Directors' Information:- R N C P FINANCE LTD. [Dissolved] CIN = U67120WB1995PLC072339

Company & Directors' Information:- T T FINANCE LIMITED [Amalgamated] CIN = U67120DL1986PLC023168

Company & Directors' Information:- M M V R FINANCE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U65921TZ1997PLC007705

Company & Directors' Information:- D B FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U65191TN1989PTC016705

Company & Directors' Information:- C H P FINANCE PVT LTD [Active] CIN = U65921PB1992PTC012788

Company & Directors' Information:- S L B P FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U74899DL1990PTC041694

Company & Directors' Information:- R S FINANCE PVT LTD [Active] CIN = U65191WB1988PTC044144

Company & Directors' Information:- I C FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U65921UP1989PTC011236

Company & Directors' Information:- V K FINANCE PVT LTD [Strike Off] CIN = U67120WB1991PTC052140

Company & Directors' Information:- C AND N FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65921DL1998PTC094290

Company & Directors' Information:- C D R FINANCE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65910TG1995PLC022237

Company & Directors' Information:- J R FINANCE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U65921PB1996PLC017699

Company & Directors' Information:- I C S FINANCE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65921TZ1987PLC001991

Company & Directors' Information:- D D S FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65910DL1996PTC076165

Company & Directors' Information:- K V L FINANCE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65191TN1989PLC016715

Company & Directors' Information:- D A S FINANCE PVT LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65921PB1993PTC012888

Company & Directors' Information:- U B FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U74899DL1992PTC051300

Company & Directors' Information:- V L G FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65910AP1997PTC027952

Company & Directors' Information:- E M S FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65921TZ1986PTC001789

Company & Directors' Information:- T D M FINANCE COMPANY PRIVATE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U65923KL1997PTC011601

Company & Directors' Information:- S. F. FINANCE COMPANY PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65921PB1996PTC018702

Company & Directors' Information:- D S L FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U65921TG1996PTC023898

Company & Directors' Information:- R D P FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U65929DL1997PTC089092

Company & Directors' Information:- S R K C FINANCE LIMITED [Amalgamated] CIN = U65999TZ1989PLC002445

Company & Directors' Information:- R K N FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65191TN1997PTC038377

Company & Directors' Information:- H A FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65993DL1987PTC027064

Company & Directors' Information:- V V A FINANCE LTD [Active] CIN = U65993WB1984PLC037171

Company & Directors' Information:- Y B FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65921CH1996PTC017745

Company & Directors' Information:- D G L FINANCE LTD [Strike Off] CIN = U67120TG1993PLC015604

Company & Directors' Information:- M S R FINANCE PVT LTD [Strike Off] CIN = U65191TN1989PTC016789

Company & Directors' Information:- S S P FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65191TN1987PTC014526

Company & Directors' Information:- C R N FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U74899DL1994PTC062802

Company & Directors' Information:- I FINANCE COMPANY LIMITED [Active] CIN = U67110DL2011PLC212268

Company & Directors' Information:- H AND Z FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U67190MH1995PTC093153

Company & Directors' Information:- Y AND K FINANCE COMPANY PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U74899DL1985PTC019837

Company & Directors' Information:- S L P FINANCE PRIVATE LTD. [Strike Off] CIN = U65923DL1985PTC021970

Company & Directors' Information:- V M FINANCE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65910PB1996PLC018339

Company & Directors' Information:- D S K FINANCE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65910UP1988PLC010317

Company & Directors' Information:- G B V FINANCE COMPANY PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65110UP1988PTC010219

Company & Directors' Information:- B H FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65922KA1995PTC018390

Company & Directors' Information:- M .R .S . FINANCE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65929DL1995PLC067184

Company & Directors' Information:- H D FINANCE LTD [Strike Off] CIN = U67120DL1986PLC023675

Company & Directors' Information:- P R K FINANCE P LTD [Strike Off] CIN = U65191TN1995PTC033478

Company & Directors' Information:- T AND C FINANCE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U67120RJ1996PLC012576

Company & Directors' Information:- W S FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65192UP1996PTC020243

Company & Directors' Information:- S A C FINANCE COMPANY PVT LTD [Active] CIN = U65999WB1985PTC039002

Company & Directors' Information:- C C FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65191TN1997PTC037805

Company & Directors' Information:- S R B FINANCE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65910UP1988PLC010045

Company & Directors' Information:- P V FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65993DL1987PTC027270

Company & Directors' Information:- R V S FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65990KA1995PTC018436

Company & Directors' Information:- P AND B FINANCE PVT LTD [Strike Off] CIN = U99999MH1986PTC038841

Company & Directors' Information:- B B P FINANCE COMPANY PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65921PB1996PTC018183

Company & Directors' Information:- A E FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U65999TZ1990PTC002905

Company & Directors' Information:- L R FINANCE COMPANY PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65910UP1988PTC009758

Company & Directors' Information:- S B M FINANCE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65921PB1994PLC014374

Company & Directors' Information:- T A S FINANCE PVT LTD [Strike Off] CIN = U65191TN1990PTC018654

Company & Directors' Information:- D AND O FINANCE COMPANY PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U74899DL1993PTC054788

Company & Directors' Information:- H R P FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65921PB1995PTC015715

Company & Directors' Information:- P T R FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65191TN1989PTC016795

Company & Directors' Information:- B & S FINANCE PVT LTD [Strike Off] CIN = U65191TN1988PTC015491

Company & Directors' Information:- H S B FINANCE PVT LTD [Strike Off] CIN = U67120RJ1996PTC012119

Company & Directors' Information:- M. J. S. FINANCE COMPANY PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65921PB1971PTC003049

Company & Directors' Information:- A R FINANCE PVT LTD [Strike Off] CIN = U65921PB1989PTC009778

Company & Directors' Information:- K G FINANCE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65910TZ1982PLC001219

Company & Directors' Information:- S AND Z FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65923PN1997PTC106520

Company & Directors' Information:- H S N FINANCE PVT LTD [Strike Off] CIN = U67120PB1993PTC013900

Company & Directors' Information:- G N FINANCE PVT LTD [Strike Off] CIN = U65990MH1981PTC024294

Company & Directors' Information:- C S FINANCE PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U65910GJ1987PTC009799

    W.P. No. 24715 of 2005

    Decided On, 17 March 2020

    At, High Court of Judicature at Madras

    By, THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE T. RAJA

    For the Petitioner: K. Raja, Advocate. For the Respondents: R1 & R4, K. Magesh, Special Government Pleader.



Judgment Text


(Prayer: Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, praying for the issue of a Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus calling for the records of the third respondent in his proceeding dated 10.03.2005 and quash the same and consequently direct the respondents herein to pay family pension of Rs.4,290/- p.m. along with other benefits with effect from March 2005 continuously until her death.)

1. The petitioner, W/o. S.R.Naidu, who is receiving family pension at Rs.4290/- p.m. with effect from 24.04.2001 as per the proceedings issued by the Chief Engineer (H&RW), Chennai, dated 11.04.2000, has filed this Writ Petition in the year 2005 challenging the correctness of the order of recovery dated 10.03.2005 issued by the 3rd respondent and seeking a direction to the respondents to pay the family pension at Rs.4,290/- p.m. along with other benefits with effect from March 2005.

2. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submitted that the petitioner's husband, while serving as Superintending Engineer Group 'C' Post, Highways Department, Chennai, attained the age of superannuation on 07.08.1963. Thereafter, initially, he was paid with monthly pension of Rs.453/- p.m. from 08.08.1963 through PPO No.A-55511. While he has been receiving monthly pension regularly during his life time, G.O.Ms.No.200 Finance (PC) Department, dated 18.05.1999 came to be issued revising the pension. Therefore, he made a representation to the 4threspondent herein, namely, Chief Engineer (H&RW), Chennai on 28.06.1999 for revising his pension. Accordingly, the 4th respondent increased his pension at Rs.6,717/- p.m. and the family pension was also fixed at Rs.4290/- p.m. on 11.04.2000. Finally, as per G.O.Ms.No.200 dated 18.05.1999, the petitioner's husband received pension of Rs.6,717/- p.m. as per the proceedings dated 23.05.2000 of the District Treasury Officer, Coimbatore, wherein it has been mentioned that the family pension has been fixed at Rs.4,290/- p.m. and the revision of pension was given to the petitioner's husband at Rs.6,717/- with effect from 01.04.1999.

3. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submitted that sadly, the husband of the petitioner died on 23.04.2001. Hence, the petitioner was given family pension at Rs.4,290/- p.m. with effect from 24.04.2001 vide Proceedings of the 4th respondent dated 11.04.2002 and the petitioner was receiving the said family pension with dearness allowance right from 24.04.2001 to 28.02.2005. While so, the Assistant General Manager, State Bank of India, Anna Nagar West Branch, Chennai, the 3rd respondent herein, passed the impugned order dated 10.03.2005 stating that an excess amount of Rs.4600/- had been paid every month as family pension from 01.12.2002. Therefore, the pension from March 2005 onwards would be paid as indicated in the Credit Report with a direction to the petitioner to remit the excess amount of Rs.1,95,937/- paid to him as family pension from 01.12.2002 to 28.02.2005. The said impugned order calling upon the petitioner to pay back the said amount is in violation of the ratio laid down by the Apex Court in the case of State of Punjab and others vs. Rafiq Masih etc., which is called famously as White Washers Case reported in CDJ 2014 SC 1054 wherein it has been held that recovery from retired employees who are due to retire within one year of the order of recovery is impermissible in law. Moreover, the impugned order was passed against the petitioner on the premise that an excess amount of Rs.1,95,937/- was paid to her, without giving any opportunity of hearing to her and no notice was issued to her calling upon her explanation and no enquiry whatsoever was also held. Hence, the impugned order of recovery passed behind the petitioner is liable to be set aside.

4. A detailed counter affidavit has been filed by respondents 1 and 4.

5. Learned Special Government Pleader appearing for respondents 1 and 4 would submit that after the death of the petitioner's husband on 23.04.2001, the petitioner was given the family pension at Rs.4,290/- with effect from 24.04.2001 as per the proceedings issued by the 4th respondent. When the family pension is given by the Government to the spouse of the deceased/petitioner for which the Government has issued various orders from time to time, the Tamil Nadu Pension Rules were introduced with effect from 01.04.1964 which states that the family pension in case of legal heir/spouse of the deceased pensioner, who retired before 01.04.1964, are eligible only for Flat Rate of Family Pension as per G.O.Ms.No.748, Finance (Pension) Department, dated 26.5.1979. Therefore, the petitioner has no right to claim family pension with reference to the orders issued in G.O.Ms.No.200, Finance (Pay Cell) Department, dated 18.5.1999 revising the pension for pre 1996 pensioners.

6. Learned Special Government Pleader further submitted that since the State Bank of India, Anna Nagar West Branch is the disbursing authority of the Family Pension, based on the audit objection raised by the Accountant General, the Chief Engineer (General), Highways has cancelled the authorisation made by him for family pension and the Pension Payment Officer, Chennai has passed orders for effecting recovery of excess payment and accordingly, the State Bank of India, Anna Nagar West Branch has effected recovery from the family pension, which is in order. Hence, the objection raised by the petitioner in the writ petition is not tenable. Moreover, the petitioner has not reported the fact of death of her husband to the Chief Engineer (General), Highways Department, even though the revision of pension has been recommended by the office of the Chief Engineer as requested by the pensioner Late S.R.Naidu that clearly shows that there is a lack of response on the part of the petitioner only with a motivation to gain the benefit of inadmissible family pension inadvertently authorised by the Chief Engineer (General), Highways Department, without taking note of the fact that the family pension in case of the employees retiring prior to 1.4.1964 before the introduction of the Tamil Nadu Pension Rules are eligible for flat rate of family pension only.

7. Now the short issue raised in the instant petition is whether the respondents are right in passing the order of recovery against the petitioner, who is the wife of late S.R.Naidu. When the petitioner's husband after retirement from service on 07.08.1963, received monthly pension of Rs.453/- per month from 08.08.1963 through P.P.O. No.A-55511. While so, G.O. Ms. No.200 Finance (PC) Department, dated 18.05.1999 came to be issued revising the pension. On the basis of the said G.O., the fourth respondent revised the pension of Rs.6,717/- and accordingly, the family pension was fixed at Rs.4,290/- per month on 11.04.2000. By applying the said G.O, the petitioner's husband received a sum of Rs.6,717/- per month towards pension as per Proceedings dated 23.05.2000 issued by the District Treasury Officer, Coimbatore. After the death of her husband on 23.04.2001, the petitioner was given family pension at Rs.4,290/- per month with effect from 24.04.2001 vide Proceedings dated 11.04.2002 issued by the fourth respondent.

8. The grievance of the petitioner is that when her husband died on 23.04.2001, she made a representation for receipt of family pension. But the fourth respondent, without due verification, has fixed the family pension at Rs.1,334/- holding that the benefit of fixation of pension at Rs.4,290/- is not admissible. Therefore, there is no mis-representation from the side of the petitioner. Secondly, the respondents, after noticing the fact that the petitioner was paid with excess pension, should have issued a notice before ordering recovery of Rs.1,95,937/-, when there was no mistake or fault on the part of the petitioner.

9. A perusal of the record shows that there was a mistake on the part of the respondents. They should have issued a notice calling upon the petitioner to give explanation as to why the excess amount paid by the respondents should not be recovered. Since no notice was served upon the petitioner before issuing recovery order and that there was no mis-representation from the petitioner, this Court has no hesitation to quash the impugned order of recovery.

10. Moreover, the Apex Court in its judgment dated 18.12.2014 in Civil Appeal No.11527 of 2014 etc. batch in the case of State of Punjab and others vs. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) etc. held that recovery from retired employees who are due to retire within one year of the order of recovery is impermissible in law. It is pertinent to extract the relevant portion as under:

'12. It is not possible to postulate all situations of hardship, which would govern employees on the issue of recovery, where payments have mistakenly been made by the employer, in excess of their entitlement. Be that as it may, based on the decisions referred to herein above, we may, as a ready reference, summarise the following few situations, wherein recoveries by the employ

Please Login To View The Full Judgment!

ers, would be impermissible in law: (i) Recovery from employees belonging to Class-III and Class-IV service (or Group 'C' and Group 'D' service). (ii) Recovery from retired employees, or employees who are due to retire within one year, of the order of recovery. (iii) Recovery from employees, when the excess payment has been made for a period in excess of five years, before the order of recovery is issued.' 11. A perusal of the above judgment clearly shows that the respondents cannot pass the above order of recovery against the petitioner, who is a widow and whose husband died on 23.04.2001 as a pensioner. Hence, the impugned proceeding is quashed. Accordingly, the writ petition stands allowed directing the respondents to re-fix the pension to the petitioner within a period of two weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. The respondents are further directed not to delay the process as the petitioner is a poor widow and a senior citizen. No costs.
O R