w w w . L a w y e r S e r v i c e s . i n



Bharmal Medical Store Civil Hospital Badnagar & Others v/s State of Madhya Pradesh & Others


Company & Directors' Information:- E-STORE INDIA PRIVATE LIMITED [Active] CIN = U51221TG2005PTC045040

Company & Directors' Information:- P. MEDICAL PRIVATE LIMITED [Strike Off] CIN = U85195TG1987PTC008112

    Civil Appeal Nos. 8590-8591, 8592 of 2018 (Arising out of SLP (C) Nos. 14871-14872, 21414 of 2015)

    Decided On, 27 August 2018

    At, Supreme Court of India

    By, THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RANJAN GOGOI
    By, THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE NAVIN SINHA & THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE K.M. JOSEPH

   



Judgment Text

Navin Sinha, J.

Leave granted.

2. The questions involved in these appeals being common, there being a minor variation in facts, they have been heard together and are being disposed by a common order. Suffice to observe, that in the limited nature of the controversy, we propose to take notice of the facts only to the extent necessary for purposes of the present order.

3. Both the appellants are lessees of the State Government for the shop premises situated within the compound of the District Hospital, Ujjain, Civil Hospital, Nagda, Khachrod, Mahidpur, Badnagar etc. They have been asked in 2013 to vacate the shop premises and shift from the Civil Hospital compound. The justification is the formulation of a Government Scheme i.e. Sardar Vallabh Bhai Patel Nishulka Aushadhi Vitaran Yojna for supply of free essential drugs to all classes of patients by the Government. It is not in dispute that the shop premises was constructed by the authorities and does not fall in the category of an unauthorized construction. It was settled with the appellants by open bid in 2000/2001. The lease period has long since expired and the lease has not been renewed.

4. Learned counsel for the appellants submits that the notice to vacate the shops in the hospital premises is arbitrary. No show cause notice with an opportunity to convince the authorities not to order removal was provided. Closure of the shop will infringe the fundamental rights of the appellants under Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution. The supply of generic medicines by the State Government will not be disturbed by the medicine shops being operated by the appellants. The presence of the shops would only aid availability of medicines to the patients.

5. Learned counsel for the State submitted that the medicine shops were permitted at a time when patients had to procure medicines on their own. With the advent of the new scheme for supplies of medicines by the Government, there exists no need for medicine shops within the hospital premises. In fact, the shop premises can be better utilized to facilitate supply of free medicines by the Government itself to the patients. The lease has long expired and no steps have been taken for renewal by the appellants.

6. We have considered the submissions. The laudable objective of the Government to ensure availability of free medicines to the patients in the civil hospital premises will have to be balanced with the competing interests of the appellants to earn their livelihood. If peaceful coexistence is possible, there is no reason why the shop premises should be shut down and the appellants be asked to vacate. The respondents in their counter affidavit have acknowledged the existence of a large number of medicine shops immediately outside the premises of the government hospital, to contend that it was sufficient to take care of the needs of patients. It is but a tacit admission by the respondents, for the need to have private medical shops in the vicinity for the convenience of the patients. Without further speculation, it would naturally be so for myriad reasons such as availability of timely supplies, logistics, nature of medicines required, etc. There can also be times when availability of a particular brand medicine may be a compelling necessity without awaiting government supply to be replenished. If for such eventualities a private medical shop is countenanced by the respondents at the gate of the hospital it is difficult to appreciate their insistence for removal of the appellants. We are, therefore, unable to sustain the notice directing the appellants to vacate, and which in any event, has been ordered without an opportunity to the appellants for presenting their case and convincing the authorities not to remove them.

7. The shop premises, as observed above, are not unauthorized structures, but leases have long expired and no steps have been taken by the appellants for renewal of their leases. The rent was Rs.300400/ . At the time of initial settlement also, it was done with the appellants on the basis of open bid. Considering the long passage of time since the lease has expired, and the appellants cannot claim an indefeasible right to continue irrespective of such considerations, we deem it proper to observe that it shall be open for the respondents to hold an open bid for the shops in question inside the hospital premises. The appellants can also participate in the same. Needless to say that the settlement will have to be made with the highest bidder. The present order cannot be construed as a complete embargo on the respondents with regard to the shop premises for all times to come. Any future eventuality, for justifiable

Please Login To View The Full Judgment!

reasons, will always leave the authority a discretion for closure of the shops for valid and germane reasons. 8. Till such fresh bids are held, the appellants shall not be disturbed but shall continue to pay the enhanced rate of rent in the manner provided for in the agreement with effect from the date of the present order. If there are any arrears of rent, it shall also be deposited at the agreed rate within a period of four weeks. The impugned orders of the High Court are set aside. The appeals are allowed.
O R







Judgements of Similar Parties

29-06-2020 Santosh Singh Gehlot Versus State of Rajasthan, Through The Secretary, Department of Medical & Health, Government of Rajasthan High Court of Rajasthan Jodhpur Bench
25-06-2020 Dr. S. Anusha Versus The Director of Medical and Health Services, Teynampet, Chennai & Others Before the Madurai Bench of Madras High Court
23-06-2020 Munna Lal Versus State of U.P. Thru. Addl. Chief Secy. Medical & Health Lko & Others High Court Of Judicature At Allahabad Lucknow Bench
17-06-2020 Dr. K.M. Senthamizhselvan, State President, Ayush Medical Welfare Association, Thiruvannamalai Versus The Government of Tamil Nadu, Represented by its Principal Secretary, Department of Health & Family Welfare, Chennai & Others High Court of Judicature at Madras
05-06-2020 Tanveer Jahan Versus All India Institute Of Medical Science, Through Its Director, New Delhi & Another National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission NCDRC
01-06-2020 Dr. G. Gowthaman Versus The Joint Director, Medical & Rural Health Services, Tiruppur & Others High Court of Judicature at Madras
01-06-2020 Dr. K.Gautham Versus The Director of Medical Education, Kilpauk, Chennai & Another Before the Madurai Bench of Madras High Court
22-05-2020 Grant Medical Foundation Ruby Hall Clinic, Pune Versus State of Maharashtra & Others High Court of Judicature at Bombay
19-05-2020 The Director, Jubilee Mission Medical College & Research Institute, Trichur & Others Versus The State of Kerala, Rep. by The Secretary To Health & Family Welfare Department, Secretariat, Thiruvananthapuram & Others High Court of Kerala
18-05-2020 K. Gautham Versus The Director of Medical Education, EVR Periyar Salai, Chennai & Another Before the Madurai Bench of Madras High Court
29-04-2020 Christian Medical College Vellore Association Versus Union Of India & Others Supreme Court of India
27-04-2020 Commercial Taxes Officer Versus M/s. Bombay Machinery Store Supreme Court of India
23-04-2020 In Re: Scientific Disposal of Bio-Medical Waste arising out of COVID-19 treatment-Compliance of BMW Rules, 2016 National Green Tribunal Principal Bench New Delhi
16-03-2020 Eswai Ponnusamy Educational & Charitable Trust Versus Registrar (Fac), Tamilnadu Mgr Medical University High Court of Judicature at Madras
13-03-2020 D. Sasirekha Versus The Assistant Secretary Medical Council of India Pocket-14, New Delhi High Court of Judicature at Madras
12-03-2020 Ernakulum Medical Centre, Rep. By Its Director, Palarivattom & Another Versus Dr. P.R. Jayasree & Another National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission NCDRC
06-03-2020 Dr. Nishigandha Ramchandra Naik Versus State of Maharashtra through Principal Secretary, Medical Education and Drugs Department Mantralaya & Another High Court of Judicature at Bombay
06-03-2020 Dr. K. Kavitha Versus State of Andhra Pradesh rep. by its Principal Secretary, Medical Health & Family Welfare Depart, Velagapudi & Others High Court of Andhra Pradesh
05-03-2020 The Tamil Nadu Dr.MGR Medical University, Rep by its Registrar, Chennai Versus The Doctors Welfare Association of Tamil Nadu, Rep by its General Secretary, Dr. K. Srinivasan & Others High Court of Judicature at Madras
03-03-2020 O. Thomas & Others Versus Dr. Abraham Jose, Prof. of Orthopaedics, Pushpagiri Medical College, Thiruvalla & Another Kerala State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission Thiruvananthapuram
03-03-2020 Ashok Kumar Gupta & Another Versus M/s. Sitalaxmi Sahuwala Medical Trust & Others Supreme Court of India
02-03-2020 District Medical Officer, Malappuram & Others Versus Azhukuthi Parambil Ayappans Son Thami & Others High Court of Kerala
24-02-2020 M. Muthusamy Versus The Director of Medical and Rural Services, DMS Compound, Chennai & Others High Court of Judicature at Madras
17-02-2020 M/s. Carenow Medical Prviate Limited, Rep. by its Director & the auth. Rep.T.Rajkumar Versus Rajesh Sodhi, The Principal Commissioner of GST & Central Excise, Coimbatore High Court of Judicature at Madras
14-02-2020 National Insurance Company Ltd. Through Its Duly Constituted Attorney Manager, National Insurance Company Ltd., New Delhi Versus M/s. Ganpati Timber Store, By Proprietor Sh. Rajesh Khadariya & Another National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission NCDRC
13-02-2020 Mala Devi Versus State of U.P. Thru Prin.Secy. Medical & Health Lko. & Others High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
10-02-2020 Ambalal V. Patel Versus Central Medical Service Society Vishwa Yuva Kendra & Others Competition Commission of India
10-02-2020 Raj Kumar Prasad & Others Versus Som Datt Medical Centre & Others Delhi State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission New Delhi
07-02-2020 Namaji Kamble V/S Sushrut Medical Care & Research Societies & Others National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission NCDRC
04-02-2020 Vasan Medical Centre (India) Pvt. Ltd. and Others. V/S Canara Bank and Others. Debts Recovery Tribunal Chennai
04-02-2020 The Indian Medical Association, Chhattisgarh & Others Versus State of Chhattisgarh & Others High Court of Chhattisgarh
30-01-2020 Rakesh Kumar Jha Versus CPIO & Jt. Secretary, Medical Council of India Central Information Commission
30-01-2020 Suani Das Versus CPIO Medical Council of India Central Information Commission
30-01-2020 Santha Medical Foundation (a Public Charitable Trust), Rep. by its Chairman & Trustee Dr. S. Saravanan & Another Versus The Commissioner of Rural Development and Local Administration, Government of Tamil Nadu, Chennai & Another High Court of Judicature at Madras
30-01-2020 Keval Ram Meena Versus CPIO and Dy. Secretary, Medical Council of India Central Information Commission
29-01-2020 K.T. Davis Versus Palana Institute of Medical Sciences, Kannadi P.O., Palakkad & Another Kerala State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission Thiruvananthapuram
24-01-2020 P.R. Girish & Others Versus Sree Sudheendra Medical Mission Hospital, Kacheripady, Ernakulam & Others Kerala State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission Thiruvananthapuram
22-01-2020 Dr. Parthsarthi Versus The Maharashtra Medical Council, Mumbai, thr. its Registrar, Mumbai & Another In the High Court of Bombay at Nagpur
21-01-2020 M/s. Ganesh Grain Store, Raniganj Bazar Ballia Versus State of U.P. & others High Court Of Judicature At Allahabad Lucknow Bench
14-01-2020 Qualified Private Medical Practitioners Association, having its Registered Office, Kottayam, Represented by Its President, Dr. O. Baby Versus Union of India, Represented by Government of India, Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, New Delhi & Others High Court of Kerala
13-01-2020 Prakash Shikshan Mandal's Loknete Versus State of Maharashtra, through its Department of Medical Education & Drugs & Others High Court of Judicature at Bombay
06-01-2020 M/s. Sukhsagar Medical College & Hospital Versus State of Madhya Pradesh & Others High Court of Madhya Pradesh
03-01-2020 Krishna Institute of Medical Sciences Ltd. & Another Versus V. Srinivas Rao & Another Telangana State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission Hyderabad
02-01-2020 R. Mahendran Versus The Director (Medical), E.S.I. Hospital, Chennai & Others High Court of Judicature at Madras
02-01-2020 Dr. V. Leelavathi Versus State of Karnataka Department of Health & Family Welfare (Medical Education) Rep. by its Additional Chief Secretary, Bengaluru & Others High Court of Karnataka
20-12-2019 Government Medical College And Post Graduate Institute & Super Specialty Hospital Versus H.C.L. Infosystemes Ltd. & Others National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission NCDRC
19-12-2019 J. Vijay Anthony Versus The Director, Directorate of Medical Education, Poonamallee High Road, Chennai & Another High Court of Judicature at Madras
18-12-2019 M/s. Medical Research Foundation, Chennai Versus The Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax (Exemptions), Chennai Circle, Chennai High Court of Judicature at Madras
11-12-2019 P. Natarajan Versus The Joint Director of Medical & Rural Health Services, Tiruppur & Others High Court of Judicature at Madras
06-12-2019 The General Manager, Indian Institute of Emergency Medical Services, Noya Plaza, Kalathippadi, Kottayam Versus Anees Benny, Vaniyakizhakkel veedu, Thodupuzha Kerala State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission Thiruvananthapuram
22-11-2019 Principal Kannur Medical College, Anjarakkandi, Kannur Versus Admission Supervisory Committee for Professional Colleges in Kerala High Court of Kerala
14-11-2019 Lilavati Kirtilal Mehta Medical Trust Versus M/s. Unique Shanti Developers & Others Supreme Court of India
13-11-2019 M. Ganesh Versus The Management, M/s. Christian Medical College & Hospital, Vellore & Another High Court of Judicature at Madras
13-11-2019 Bijili School of Nursing, rep. by its Correspondent, B. Ravinder Reddy Versus The State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary, Health, Medical & Family Welfare (KI) Department, Secretariat & Others High Court of for the State of Telangana
07-11-2019 Gyan Mishra Versus Sahara India Medical Institute Limited & Others National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission NCDRC
07-11-2019 K. Vasudevan Versus Director of Medical & Rural Service, Tamil Nadu Government & Others High Court of Judicature at Madras
05-11-2019 Dharma Medical Research & Charitable Trust, Rep. by its Trustee Versus The Union of India, Rep. By the Secretary to Government, Ministry of Ayush, New Delhi & Others High Court of Judicature at Madras
04-11-2019 S. Jayaraman Versus Properirtor/Manager, Sri Kannan Departmental Store (P) Ltd. National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission NCDRC
04-11-2019 State of Kerala, Represented by The Secretary to Government, Water Resources (Ground Water) Department, Government Secretariat, Thiruvananthapuram & Another Versus Rajendran, Store in Charge, Office of Assistant Executive Engineer, Central Workshop & Stores, Ground Water Department, Kureepuzha, Kollam High Court of Kerala
01-11-2019 Dr. S. Jaikish Versus The Medical Council of India, Rep. by its Secretary, New Delhi & Others High Court of Judicature at Madras
23-10-2019 C. Ponnusamy V/S Union of India, Rep. by the Director General Indian Council of Medical Research, Ministry of Health And Family Welfare, New Delhi And Others Before the Madurai Bench of Madras High Court
22-10-2019 R. Devasenathipathi Versus 1.Joint Director of Medical and Rural Service, Vellore & Others High Court of Judicature at Madras
18-10-2019 R. Siranjith Versus The Deputy Controller of Examination, The Tamil Nadu Dr.M.G.R.Medical University, Chennai & Others High Court of Judicature at Madras
18-10-2019 The Management of Coimbatore District Consumers Cooperative Wholesale Store Limited, Rep. by its Personnel Officer Incharge, Coimbatore Versus The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Coimbatore & Another High Court of Judicature at Madras
17-10-2019 Shobha Desai Versus The Dean Goa Medical College & Others In the High Court of Bombay at Goa
15-10-2019 Miraj Medical Centre Miraj through Medical Superintendent & Others Versus Sunil Tukaram Danane & Another High Court of Judicature at Bombay
14-10-2019 Bhumika Choudhary Versus All India Institute of Medical Sciences High Court of Delhi
14-10-2019 Annai J.K.K Sampoorani Ammal Charitable Trust, Erode Versus The Registrar, Tamil Nadu Dr. MGR Medical University, Chennai & Another High Court of Judicature at Madras
10-10-2019 M/s. Goutam Shoe Store & Another Versus Relaxo Footwear Ltd. High Court of Delhi
27-09-2019 Umran Begum Versus Institute of Post Graduate Medical Institute and Research (S.S.K.M Hospital), Through its Director West Bengal State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission Kolkata
27-09-2019 Postgraduate Institute of Medical Education & Research, Chandigarh & Another Versus Darshan Kaur Cheema & Another High Court of Punjab and Haryana
23-09-2019 Bhartiya Ayurvedic Medical College thru. Chairman Dr. Dinesh Versus U.O.I. thru. Ministry of Ayush New Delhi & Others High Court Of Judicature At Allahabad Lucknow Bench
19-09-2019 Yerra Trinadh & Others Versus State of Andhra Pradesh rep. by its Secretary, Medical Health and Family Welfare Department, Guntur Dist. & Others High Court of Andhra Pradesh
12-09-2019 Beehive Ayurvedic Medical College & Hospital & Another Versus Union of India & Another High Court of Delhi
11-09-2019 Rekha Versus Medical Council of India High Court of Karnataka Circuit Bench At Dharwad
10-09-2019 S. Malathi (Minor), Represented by her Mother, S. Uma Maheswari, Nagapattinam Versus The Tamil Nadu Dr. M.G.R. Medical University, Chennai & Others High Court of Judicature at Madras
09-09-2019 L. Rani Versus The State of Telangana, Health, Medical & Family Welfare Department, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Telangana Secretariat, Hyderabad & Others High Court of for the State of Telangana
06-09-2019 Kharagpur Homeopathic Medical College & Hospital & Another Versus Union of India & Others High Court of Judicature at Calcutta
05-09-2019 The Chief Executive Trustee Lisie Medical & Educational Institutions, Kochi Versus The Kerala University of Health Science, Represented by Its Registrar, Trichur & Others High Court of Kerala
02-09-2019 Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research Chandigarh Versus M/s Kalsi Construction Company Supreme Court of India
02-09-2019 Government of Kerala, Represented by The Secretary, Department of Health, Government Secretariat, Thiruvananthapuram & Others Versus P. Gopinathan, Associate Professor (Under Order of Removal), Department of Orthopaedics, Medical College Hospital, Kozhikode & Others High Court of Kerala
29-08-2019 Subramanian Versus The Joint Director Medical & Rural Health Services, Nagerocil, Kanyakumari & Others Before the Madurai Bench of Madras High Court
27-08-2019 Prahlad Raut Versus All India Institute of Medical Sciences Supreme Court of India
22-08-2019 M. Pandian Versus The Director of Medical Services, Chennai & Others High Court of Judicature at Madras
21-08-2019 Gujarat Medical Education & Research Society Versus Dinesh Thakur High Court of Gujarat At Ahmedabad
21-08-2019 Vishnu Ayurveda Medical College Palakkad, Represented by Its Director, P. Ramachandran Nair & Others Versus Admission Supervisory Committee for Professional Colleges in Kerala, Thiruvananthapuram, Represented by Its Chairman & Another High Court of Kerala
19-08-2019 Sri Muthukumaran Medical College, Hospital & Research Institute, Chikkarayapuram, Rep. by Chairperson, Gomathi Ammal Versus The Registrar, The Tamil Nadu, Dr. M.G.R. Medical University, Chennai & Others High Court of Judicature at Madras
19-08-2019 Association of Medical Super Speciality Aspirants & Residents & Others Versus Union of India & Others Supreme Court of India
14-08-2019 V. Balasundar Raj Versus The Director, Shree Mookambika Institute of Medical Sciences Kulasekharam Kanyakumari District Tamilnadu & Another Tamil Nadu State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission Chennai
09-08-2019 Tamil Nadu Medical Services Corporation Limited, Egmore, Chennai & Others Versus Tamil Nadu Medical Services Corporation Employees Welfare Union, Royapettah, Chennai & Others High Court of Judicature at Madras
09-08-2019 Meragal Pelige Dinuka Namalee Dissanayake, Bambalapitiya & Others Versus Sri Lanka Medical Council, Colombo & Others Supreme Court of Sri Lanka
09-08-2019 M/s. Maria Homeopathic Medical College & Hospital, Rep. By Principal Perai, Thiruvattar, Kanyakumari Versus The Union of India, Rep. By Ministry of Ayurveda, Yoga & Naturopathy, Unani, Siddha & Homeopathy (AYUSH), New Delhi & Others Before the Madurai Bench of Madras High Court
09-08-2019 Raja Sri Priya, Rep. by her father & natural guardian, G. Guruvaraju Versus The Director, Directorate of Medical Education, Kilpauk, Chennai & Others High Court of Judicature at Madras
07-08-2019 Syeda Sana Fatima & Others Versus The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary Health, Medical & Family Welfare Department & Others High Court of for the State of Telangana
05-08-2019 Tata Sia Airlines Limited Versus M/s Pilot18 Aviation Book Store & Another High Court of Delhi
01-08-2019 KVG Ayurveda Medical College, Rep. by its Principal N.S. Shettar Versus Government of India, Rep. by its Secretary Ministry of Ayurveda, New Delhi & Others High Court of Karnataka
30-07-2019 Rakesh Sharma & Others Versus All India Institute of Medical Sciences High Court of Madhya Pradesh
30-07-2019 Dr. Amit Kumar Verma & Others Versus All India Institute of Medical Sciences High Court of Madhya Pradesh
26-07-2019 P. Karuppasamy Versus State of Tamil Nadu, Rep. By its Principal Secretary, Department of Medical Education, Chennai & Others Before the Madurai Bench of Madras High Court
19-07-2019 Dr. Nikhil Raheja Versus Medical Council of India & Others High Court of Delhi


LawyerServices is a Premium Legal Tech solution.


Lawyers, Law Firms, Government Departments and Corporates rely on us for, Workflow Automation, Data Aggregation, Timely Updates, Case Management, Intelligent Research, Latest Legal Data Updates and a LOT more!

If you are a legal professional, CONTACT US, in order to see how our UNIQUE solution can benefit your organization.

Features Intro Close Box